Smartphones Turbocharged Reading Decline
October 5, 2026
Reading has been in decline for decades. Joel Halldorf from LitHub agrees with this statement in his article: “Did Smartphones Really Kill Reading?” He points out that Rose Horowitch from The Atlantic says that reading is: “brief and distracted, quite different from the focused attention encouraged by print. Modern readers may still be able to decode words, Horowitch argues, but they struggle to comprehend longer texts. Our society is not illiterate, but post-literate.”
Reading has been in decline long before the smartphone was invented. Literary critic George Seiner said that the gradual end to reading started in the 1950s with the growth of radio, cinema, and television then accelerated in the 1980s.
Reading should and probably will be protected by certain groups of people. That can be done by protecting the printed book:
“Digital devices can help us find information quickly, but print is better suited to focused reading. Schools therefore need to continue championing books, yet the trend has lately moved in the opposite direction. In 2022, the National Council of Teachers of English declared that it was time to “decenter book reading” in order to address “inequalities in digital technologies and competencies.” But equity can be used as an argument in support of the opposite approach. Children who do not grow up surrounded by books depend on schools to introduce them to sustained reading. Like computers, printed books are a technology that must be learned.”
The second way to protect reading is having space where reading is the normal practice and third is making reading social again. Halldorf is pointing out the true history that radio started the downward trend then smartphones and other devices turbocharged it. He does provide a hopeful future, if only it will happen. Note: I heard that book stores are the go-to places to meet people who … wait for it … like to read. Amazing.
Whitney Grace, October 5, 2026
Teen Readership: Doom Scrolling Is the Thing
September 23, 2026
The trusted news outlet Reuters reports that teen readership is at an all time low in the article: “Teen Reading Slumps To Worst This Century Due To Surge In Screen Time.” Remember that report a few weeks ago that Gen Alpha is dumber than Gen Z? Reading scores are at an all time for a number of reasons. The main cause is that teens are spending more time on screen. Books are the losers in the Age of Doom Scrolling. In the United States, youngsters learn to read as if they were deciphering ideographs. Phonices and “sounding out”? Nope, that’s for losers in many American schools.
The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development tested 760,000 fifteen-year-olds from 91 countries in science, mathematics, and reading. The results were the lowest since the organization started collecting data in 2000. I learned:
“On average, students were reading at a level that had in the past been expected of students one year younger, according to the OECD’s latest Program for International Student Assessment released on Tuesday. A 2012 reading high of 501 on PISA’s index had declined to a score of 466 last year. The test is widely regarded as the world’s leading gauge of educational performance ?and its results are closely scrutinized by governments and educators.”
Kids are reading quickly through a text, but missing information and are getting wrong answers. Another problem is that kids are using AI chatbots to do the reading. Some students then rely on smart software to draft essays, summarize texts and for research, and do the grunt work that once required a trip to the library. As a result, many students achieve a much lower score in science.
Is there a fix? No.
Can you name a company happy to inject shaped information into the minds of mobile and smart software dependent students? Pick from the list below:
- [a] Anthropic
- [b] Google
- [c] Meta
- [d] OpenAI.
This is the type of test young students prefer. You may have an opportunity to hire some in the near future.
Whitney Grace, September 23, 2026
Lecturing to Those AI Users Who Take What AI Outputs. Period.
August 28, 2026
Another dinobaby post. No AI unless it is an image. This dinobaby is not Grandma Moses, just Grandpa Arnold.
Let me boil down 2,300 words to a summary: Do the work. Yep, that’s what “The Missing Layer in AI-Assisted Research: Evidence Assurance” struck me as asserting. The problem, in my opinion, is unlikely to go away. Even if the US BAIT outfits go belly up and decay in the koi pond, the AI cat is out of the bag. Let’s take three examples I have encountered in the last month (today is August 23, 2026):
- At a local joint called El Nopal, I heard a group of Spanish speaking teens telling one another how smart software could take their Spanish language essays, fix them up, and then present them is English. How old were the teens? I estimated about 15, maybe 16. I remember the cluelessness I faced when I attended the local school in Campinas, Brazil, in the 1950s. If I had a smart software system to help me, would I have used it? In case you are struggling for my answer, here it is: “Of course I would have used it.” I spoke only English and school was 100 percent Brazilian Portuguese.
- A former CIA contact and I attended a local entrepreneur show-and-tell. There were nine speakers. Eight of them used Google Gemini to produce their “art.” One presenter just talked. I asked him who assisted him in putting together his remarks which were textbook 1960 speech class in structure. He said, “ChatGPT.” Okay, that sample rings the bell for 100 percent smart software enabled. By the way, the proposed start up ideas were in need of work.
- I needed a plumber. I made some calls. A registered fellow turned up. He fixed the lead. He had a nifty plastic wrap on his truck. I asked, “Who designed the graphic?” He said, “The plastic sign shop. I told the person at the counter what I wanted. She used some AI system. It printed out two graphics with my name, the slogan “We don’t drain your wallet,” and said, “Pick one. I did. Looks cool, doesn’t it?” Yep, cool.

Thanks, MidJourney. Good enough.
The write up asserts:
When AI research tools first arrived, I immediately saw their advantage as a way to socialize research at scale. Anyone can ask a question and get an answer in seconds, increasing their curiosity about our customers and how to better serve them. But that speed can bypass the methodological discipline market research has spent more than 80 years developing to make its findings credible: documenting where evidence came from, how it was collected, and how much confidence to place in it.
In my three examples, exactly zero cared about any verification or validation. The “good enough” AI is indeed pretty good for my three use cases.
The cited essay says:
Yet the person receiving the answer often has no simple way to know what the AI could actually see, which evidence it used, what it skipped, or how directly its conclusions trace back to primary research. The analyst, research team, and VP can all receive the same confident response without knowing how much assurance the evidence underneath it warrants.
The author is correct. But most users don’t care. If output comes from a computer, it is definitely more “right” than looking at a link and trying to figure out where the possibly incorrect factoid the search system user wants is lurking. That’s too much work for most people. Therefore, smart software is a work reducer. Anyone who wants to use AI for something serious knows that validation and verification are real work. Then people like the former head of the ethics department or the former president of Stanford just do the easy thing, emulating the students eating burritos at El Nopal.
The essay concludes in a series of statements that sound a great deal like my high school debate coach, Kenneth Harris. Ponder this passage:
I’m using the levels of Evidence Assurance to communicate when different degrees of evidentiary assurance are appropriate for market research and business decision-making. A researcher might use a Directional Skill for a low-stakes, repetitive task; a Grounded system when the answer needs to come from the actual research library; and an Auditable system when the evidence may need to withstand scrutiny from a client, executive, legal team, or another researcher.
You don’t need to become a market researcher or a data scientist to use AI well. The same questions apply here as in other research:
Where is the information coming from?
How confident should you be that the answer is accurate?
What are the consequences if the answer is wrong?
Research already has ways to answer those questions: sampling tells us where the data came from, margin of error how much confidence to place in it, and methodology what a finding can and cannot support. AI has made research faster while often stripping away those signals.
The only way to alter the widespread use of smart software, cause people like AI using lawyers to verify case law, and get academics to do academic-like work is to turn off AI. Flip the switch. Kill it.
We know that won’t happen; therefore, what’s the point of explaining the process of verifying and validating information. The horse had fled the barn. The barn burned to the ground. An AI outfit bought the land and will erect a data center where it once stood. Too bad for the horse, right, Pilgrim?
Net net: New rules will emerge. Who will enforce them? Essays won’t do the trick.
Stephen E Arnold, August 28, 2026
From Tech First to Tech Worst in the Classroom
August 5, 2026
In my opinion, an entire generation of students are going to be mentally wonky because they were educated with screens. I fear that these young people will be outsmarted by a gerbil or a rock. Fortune in “Hey, we told you so” article, “Schools Across America Are Quietly Admitting That Screens In Classrooms Made Students Worse Off And Are Reversing Years Of Tech-First Policies” is pointing out what quite a few people thought was obvious. Schools are learning that assigning everything student a laptop wasn’t the best idea when it comes to obtaining knowledge that allows a student to perform well on standardized tests. (Sure, I know standardized tests arrive with tons of scuffed and scattered luggage. Nevertheless, some can be useful.)
The clued in Fortune article says:
“Citing the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS), Horvath said: “Frequent in-class computer use correlates with significantly lower math and science performance across both high-income and middle-income countries.” This study showed fourth-graders’ and eighth-graders’ test scores correlated with whether they were using laptops almost never on the high-end versus almost daily on the low-end.”
Laptop manufacturers have had an influence on public schools. Laptops sold to schools promise to increase student performance. Whether a Mac, Windows laptop, or Chromebooks, the with-it education professionals bought the pitch hook, line, and sinker. Who wants a student to use an outdated laptop. Therefore, upgrade. Could that money be used for other education-related actions; for example, paying teachers pumping up in-service training, or providing certain classes with an in-class human aid to assist the student in his or her learning?
After a couple of decades of doing the techno-boogie, some schools have figured out that technology has to do more than create doomscrolling masters. Some instructors are making students take notes with pen and paper as Abraham Lincoln did. In the US, Gen Z is notable because it allegedly is the first generation not to score higher than their predecessors in measures of academic achievement:
“Distractions are a major culprit of this degradation of learning, Horvath previously told Fortune, adding that refocusing attention after it’s been diverted takes time to recover. Educational systems “screwed up,” he told Fortune. ‘And I genuinely hope Gen Z quickly figures that out and gets mad.’”
Gen Z might be mad, but they also might be too distracted by their screens to get upset. Take that back, they’ll make a TikTok rant, wait for it to go viral, then become outraged. Emotions are based on what’s trending these days. But what about Fortune’s intense, timely coverage of this issue?
Okay, just decades after the digital assault on learning began.
Whitney Grace, August 5, 2026
Long-Term Bad News. Not What I Need Today
July 31, 2026
Another dinobaby post. No AI unless it is an image. This dinobaby is not Grandma Moses, just Grandpa Arnold.
As a dinobaby, I try my best to avoid bad news. I have enough about which to worry. When one is 82, I like to look for the bright spots, the upside, the happy places. Today (July 24, 2026) my trusty newsfeed set up delivered a couple of gems to me. Because I am old and mostly addled, I link factoids. I look for patterns into which to fit some of the crazy data flowing through my hopelessly old-fashioned computer set up. (Who says four megabytes of RAM is not enough?)
The first item was “Meet Carnegie Mellon Computer Science PhD Yang Zhilin, Who Left US to Build Chinese AI Model Shaking Silicon Valley.” The write up explained:
Carnegie Mellon University computer science Ph.D. Yang Zhilin left the U.S. to build Moonshot AI in China, whose new open-weight Kimi K3 model is sending shockwaves through Silicon Valley. Moonshot AI unveiled Kimi K3 late last week, a 2.8 trillion-parameter open-weight large language model designed for complex reasoning, software coding and analyzing long documents. It said it will release the model weights on July 27, allowing developers to download, fine-tune and build on it. Its coding and AI agent capabilities rival leading models from U.S. companies including OpenAI and Anthropic while operating at substantially lower cost, marking another milestone for China’s AI industry…
Pittsburgh is a wonderful city. CMU is a good school. What’s not to like? The steel mill miasma is gone. There’s even a hockey team.

Thanks, Midjourney. Good enough.
The write up said:
Yang’s success has also fueled debate in the U.S. over retaining top AI talent. Prominent investor Vinod Khosla argued that restrictive immigration policies were driving talented researchers away.
Maybe? One of Zhilin’s CMU professors is quoted as saying:
Yang’s decision had little to do with U.S. immigration challenges. While acknowledging that the immigration process can be intimidating and “uncertain,” he said Yang had always intended to return to China and build his own startup.
My take is that Zhilin wanted the information, but he is Chinese. One of my Chinese friends told me, “No matter where you go in the world, you are always Chinese.”
The second item was “Every State Ranked by Its Math and Reading Test Scores, from Worst to Best.” I have learned to provide exact change when paying for a product at a convenience store. Why? Young cashiers cannot make change. At one store, the check out person did not know what a $2 bill was and had to call the manager. The busy manager required about five minutes to appear at the check out lane and say, “Yep, that’s a $2 bill.”
Working through the list from the top state Massachusetts to the lowest ranking state New Mexico (have you ever been to Grants, New Mexico? If not, when you arrive, take it from me: Pay using exact change if you use cash.) I fiddled around with the data and noted that the difference in “scores” between the top ranked state and the lowest ranked state was 56 points for math and 23 points for eighth graders. I know zero about education, but I know that Chinese students perform at a higher level. For example, one of my contacts told me that the different is the equivalent of three or four grade levels. The issue was so significant that this person sent his son to China in the summer to study math. For Eastern European students in the same age group, one of my contacts told me, “We have our daughter attend math tutoring online with a Ph.D. in Kiev.”
Observations, of course, are warranted:
- A mastery of reading, writing, and arithmetic seems important in today’s world even if the media explain that AI will replace humans at work.
- Individuals who are not anchored in fundamental knowledge tools like reading comprehension, mathematics, and written communications may have a major problem recognizing certain types of communications and verifying the information in them.
- Certain individuals who are fortunate enough to have access to additional educational resources will demonstrate higher performance on certain types of evaluations. The question is, “Does a country have enough intelligent young people?”
Net net: Bureaucracy is not education. An iPad is not education. A mobile phone is not education. And what is taking place in American schools, if these data are semi accurate and reproducible, is not education. I am glad I am a dinobaby who can make change.
Stephen E Arnold, July 31, 2026
Reverse AI Fibonacci: The Spiral of Stupid
July 21, 2026
Another dinobaby post. No AI unless it is an image. This dinobaby is not Grandma Moses, just Grandpa Arnold.
I read an interesting article in the online publication Tech Radar. Its title? “‘Quality Decays Exponentially Following AI Arrival’: Research Shows Experts and Contributors Leaving Online Communities Amidst Silent Knowledge Reset.” I am not going to illustrate my view point with one of those MBA hockey stick diagrams. Nope, I am going with the Fibonacci sequence or what I call the Spiral of Stupid. First, though, let’s look at what the write up says.

Here we have a professor explaining the Fibonacci inversion; that is, start with a large value IQ and decrement according the the algorithm. The result is that the person relying on social media ends up an intellectual zero. Hey, don’t like my blunt statement? Just go to a local store and pay in cash. Watch the expression on the face of the young person at the smart cash register. Better yet, ask a college student what Fibonacci is. Thanks, MidJourney. I like the teacher’s shirt. Very TikTok.
I noted this passage:
AI, which arguably bridges the gap between most entry-level and mid-range coders and some of the best in the business, might actually be accelerating the latter’s exit from online communities, as they feel their efforts are no longer as valued as they once were. Stack Overflow has seen a nearly 76% decline in monthly questions posted since ChatGPT’s advent in 2022, indicating that both new and existing users are abandoning the site.
One lousy online community, and the sky is falling. The article doesn’t share my larger concern about the impact of AI on education, authentic discourse, and respect for intellectual property’s knowledge value.
The write up adds:
… researchers indicate it could spill over into other areas such as classrooms, offices, and other research communities, where low-effort answers are harder to discern from those of subject-matter experts thanks to ever-evolving, retrained AI models.
Indicate? I think one might want to use a more pointed work. How about “demonstrate” or “make evident” or “know.” But that’s too direct. One would not want to raise broader intellectual issues about smart software, would one?Here’s
I circled this statement in the article:
“If everybody can create a good quality response or output using AI, some people may think, ‘Why should I make an effort to share my expertise and participate?”, publisher of the study Dr Kenny Ching explained. Ching termed this ‘signal compression’ as expert and non-expert solutions became harder to separate, even as it became less rewarding to be a subject-matter expert on topics that AI could also easily weigh in on.
Okay, very delicate. I am a dinobaby, and I am clumsy too. Therefore, I shall offer several observations:
- AI is a short cut to appearing smarter than one actually is.
- Use of AI eliminates the need to do the grunt work that allows a person to internalize certain information and knowledge patterns, and learn to use the recognition of these patterns in fresh, and hopefully for some, interesting and novel ways to create “new” information.
- AI is supposed to be the next big thing. What’s it delivered? Crazy behavior from large companies that should know about measured decision making and prudent governance of their institutions. Students who cannot read but who can watch TikTok-type videos for extended periods of time. Researchers who fake data to get grants or click along the tenure track. Smart weapons that are mostly accurate. Mostly. Just don’t ask too many questions, please.
Net net: This is not just a Stack Overflow problem. This is THE problem for any knowledge value activity.
Stephen E Arnold, July 21, 2026
Bet You Did Not Know This: College Students Cannot Read at Grade Level
July 16, 2026
Current college students are reading at elementary school levels says Futurism in the article, “College Students Are Testing At The Level of 10-Year-Olds.”? ? According to a recent study conducted by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development that surveyed adult skills from thirty-eight high income countries (most of them in the west) a portion of students in college are performing at extremely low levels. Their abilities would be alarming if these kids were in middle school.
Here are some of the numbers:
“The survey, first spotted by the Economist, tested around 160,000 people of all ages, across all 38 member states. It found that across all OECD member countries, a full 8 percent of college students are reading at the level of a ten-year-old, if not worse. While countries like Germany and France rang in at under 5 percent, countries like Poland, Israel, and the United States blew the curve at 21, 20, and 14 percent, respectively.”
They get worse with math:
“The numbers aren’t much better when it comes to math. Across OECD countries, 9 percent of college students do math at or below a ten-year-old level. In Italy, the US, and Slovakia, that figure jumps to over 15 percent — only outdone by Israel, where roughly 21 percent of college students were underachieving at the same low benchmark.”
Why are kids not doing so hot? There are multiple explanations, including pandemic-era learning gaps, declining college admissions so they lower the standards, and lower funding for public education. The results also coincide with LLMs being used by students to cheat. If technology is removed from schools, it would offer a significant boost.
Technology literacy is important, but when screens become ingrained in kids from birth maybe it’s time to try a more luddite approach. These poor kids can’t make changes either, just like their adult counterparts.
Whitney Grace, July 16, 2026
Live for Your Brain and Work Longer
June 29, 2026
Your hope for retirement is delayed with this paper released by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER): “Does Employment Slow Cognitive Decline? Evidence From Labor Market Shocks.” The study shows that the longer adults work into their golden years the less likely they are to develop and show cognitive decline. Here’s the abstract:
“With large gains in life expectancy, the population share of disability due to cognitive decline and dementia has substantially increased. Many older adults in the United States leave the workforce well before age 65. Correlational evidence suggests that leaving the workforce before retirement age could accelerate the pace of cognitive decline. We offer causal evidence, using HRS data for the United States, exploiting plausibly exogenous shifts in labor demand in local labor markets as a Bartik instrument for employment variation across these markets. We find substantial declines over time in cognitive scores stemming from negative labor demand shocks. These findings are concentrated among men aged 51 to 64, whose employment decisions and outcomes may be more sensitive to local labor market conditions than are these decisions or outcomes for women or for older men. Our evidence extends past work focusing narrowly on the retirement age window and provides further support to the notion that working to older ages may delay age-related cognitive decline.”
This is horrible news for people wanting to retire early and enjoy their latter years. From another standpoint it sounds like the NBER is trying to rationalize not hiring younger people because of the proven incompetencies related to attention spans, cognitive development, and casual adulting. Is this a way to prevent social security payouts and people going on Medicare?
Or maybe it’s a genuine concern about human cognitive decline and is encouraging people to do what’s best for themselves to keep their brains healthy.
The idea seems to mesh nicely with the mantras of the tech bros. Humanoids must work longer and harder. Only the Top 10 percent will succeed. The top of the Top 10 percent will be able to fix up the problems of the humanoids who are not sufficiently intelligent to run modern social constructs. Citizen, obey.
Whitney Grace, June 29, 2026
Google: Need a Job. You Are Trainable for Manual Labor
June 24, 2026
Career coaches are recommending to young people to consider a skilled trade instead of the typical four year college degree. Why? The skilled tradespeople of the world are disappearing. There are also people who earned a bachelor’s degree, but they can’t find a job, so they’re learning a trade instead. Google has jumped onto the skilled trade bandwagon says Construction Dive in the article: “Google Pledges $50M For Skilled Trades Training.” The write up asserts:
Google isn’t the only company investing money in skilled laborers. Meta and Monday are doing similar investments. With the $50 million, Google plans to support fourteen labor unions and reach 300,000 workers across twenty states. The plan is to better educate new workers and level up training/outreach. Unlike its counterparts who want the new wave of workers to construct data centers, Google simply wants people interested in trades and will support them “no matter where they want to work.”
Here’s how Google plans to work with the trades:
“TradesFutures, an organization created by North America’s Building Trades Unions, will increase union construction career access by scaling placement for apprenticeship readiness and registered apprenticeship programs. Google previously had invested in the electrical training Alliance — an organization created by the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers and the National Electrical Contractors Association — intending to train 100,000 electrical workers and 30,000 new apprentices in the U.S. Now, etA will aid local training programs by bringing resources to infrastructure hubs in a mobile training center pilot. Meanwhile, the United Association’s International Training Fund, in partnership with the Mechanical Contractors Association of America, will develop a five-year roadmap for scaling the plumbing, heating, ventilation, air conditioning and refrigeration sectors. That will help give workers skills necessary for the construction and maintenance of infrastructure for data center builds. Finally, the International Training Institute for the Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Industry, backed by the Sheet Metal, Air, Rail, and Transportation Workers and Sheet Metal and Air Conditioning Contractors, will modernize its coursework and apprentice support and implement new AI tools.”
Skilled trade workers are an important part of any Googley economy. I wonder if Google knows that some of its employees as well as assorted art history majors will be lining up to be trained. Training works if the person being trained tunes in.
Whitney Grace, June 24, 2026
Another Annoying Alarm Goes Off: Big AIT Tech is Deskilling Experts
June 23, 2026
Another dinobaby post. No AI unless it is an image. This dinobaby is not Grandma Moses, just Grandpa Arnold.
I think I have pounded on the AI alarm button previously. Here i go again: Pound, pound, pound. I read “Is AI Ruining Our Skills? Early Results Are In. And They Are Not Good.” Is this a study about doom scrolling GenAI kids? Is this a study about hormone infused 14 year olds? Is this a study about a bored 20 something working at Dairy Queen? Nope. Nope. And nope.
I wanted the colonoscopy cartoon but guard rails are there to protect me. Thanks, MidJourney. Barely good enough.
The write up is about doctors and engineers. The Nature article says:
Seventy per cent of nurses and 77% of physicians, for example, are worried about losing their skills because of over-reliance on AI systems, according to a survey of US health-care workers published earlier this month. Their fear might be justified. Evidence suggests that AI-driven ‘deskilling’ is starting to happen in medicine, computer science and other fields. Researchers are now discussing how to preserve important human expertise in the age of AI.
People, even smart adults, love convenience. Why walk? Drive. Why hit the farmer’s market? Go to TraderJoe’s. Why read a dull PDF about a new process? Let ChatGPT present “facts” in McDonald’s chicken nuggets of information. It is 2026. Go fast. Accelerate. Do what makes one feel groovy.
The write up uses a fun colonoscopy data set. I learned but did not experience:
Once physicians began using it [an AI tool], their performance dropped significantly whenever the system was unavailable. During the three-month period before the AI tool was introduced, the specialists found at least one adenoma during 28.4% of colonoscopies. During the three-month period after the tool was introduced, the adenoma detection rate for colonoscopies performed without AI assistance decreased to 22.4%.
Great. Just miss that precursor to colon cancer or overlook the cancer itself.
The BAIT (big AI tech) folks say that using AI makes a person smarter. Yeah, maybe in a marketing meeting. But when doing the colonoscopy thing, AI makes some smart people lazy and/or dumb.
Several observations are warranted:
- Learning, even for smart people, is hard work. People love short cuts. Short cuts in learning mean an individual is working to make oneself less smart.
- AI companies are in “if we build it, people will come.” That may be true. But if what’s delivered is intellectual heroin, is this great idea an appropriate one for society? Of course not. The goal is money and to be a winner or a monopoly or all three.
- Are studies of the negative effect of AI going to prove that AI is a great step forward? Maybe? Maybe not?
Net net: The new fire seems to burn expertise. But I am a dinobaby, and I work the dumb way. What do I know? I struggle to order a vanilla cone at the local ice cream shop. The service professional has the scoop in one hand and a mobile phone in the other.
Stephen E Arnold, June 23, 2026

