Israel Has Nailed Ad Tracking
October 28, 2026
We already know that the Internet is spying on us and using our data to sell targeted ads. It’s scary but it is the way of the Internet, but what if that data was harnessed for something else like a big old spy network. Say what? The Times of Israel report on what one of their country’s companies did: “Israeli Company Used Online Ads To Run Vast Spy Operation, Researchers Say.”
The Israeli digital advertising agency Discover-Tech spied on users through their ads and hacked their devices.? ? Discover-Tech gave the US blacklisted company Candiru access to advertising platforms run by Big Tech companies. This information was discovered by the Canadian watchdog group Citizen Lab and New York-based advertising security firm Confiant.
Here’s what happened:
“Discover-Tech’s online ads — often for ordinary products such as phones or earpods — reached more than 120,000 websites and 75,000 apps through its various partnerships, Citizen Lab said. Users who visited sites or used apps with the malicious ads could be identified and tracked by Discover-Tech, which would sometimes also try to extract phone numbers from some smartphone users, the researchers said. Ads only needed to load on a website for the spying to occur. Some ads would be used to help plant spyware from Candiru on users’ devices, both research groups said, though Confiant said that ads it tied to Candiru were a tiny fraction of Discover-Tech’s overall volume.”
Discover-Tech delivered nearly ten million ads a day and tracked people with cookie matching outside of the ads. The company had been suspended and blacklisted in many countries.
This is a powerful tool with implications that stem beyond targeted ads for the latest and greatest junk:
“Advertising-driven surveillance is increasingly being seen as a national security threat. Earlier this year, the Pentagon said it had received reports that US forces deployed to war zones had been targeted using location data harvested by ad tech firms and data brokers. Branches of the military have since disabled ad tracking on some devices.”
Consider these questions:
- Is Israel’s ad tracking worse, equal to, or better than the American approach?
- How easy is it for an entity equipped with ad tracking data and access to third-party data sets to perform cross correlation for additional insights?
- What other applications besides “personalizing your online experience” do ad data enable?
- What firms have the most detailed ad tracking data available to them and refreshed in real time on a global scale?
- Is Israel a comparable player?
Net net: What about those apps with in-app ads? What about those easy-to-use QR codes? What about … oh, never mind. I don’t want to depress you.
Whitney Grace, October 28, 2026
Government Dating Service: What Will AI Do If Plugged In?
October 6, 2026
Another dinobaby post. No AI unless it is an image. This dinobaby is not Grandma Moses, just Grandpa Arnold.
Singapore Samizdat published “How Singapore’s Government-Run Dating Service Works, and Why It Won’t Solve the Nation’s Dating Woes.” [Note: “Samizdat” refers to copies of banned documents. These were hand-copied or typewriter-generated copies. It was not a plus to have a samizdat on your bunk in some countries, comrade.’]
The cited article presents images of the questionnaire for Singapore’s apparently non-social citizens to complete. The computer crunches the data and provides a list of suitable matches. The article labels the service as “a government-run matchmaker.” The article reports:
On FirstDate’s website, one line stands out: “FirstDate uses a Nobel prize-winning framework called the Gale-Shapley Stable Marriage Algorithm”. It’s a brow-raising detail because, despite the name, the algorithm has almost nothing to do with marriage, but more on this later. The dating service will use Singpass to verify the identity of users, match people in cycles (you get only one match each cycle), and share contact details only when both users agree to their match.

Thanks, Midjourney. Good enough.
The write up includes some of the questions; for example:
- How often do you find an excuse to leave the country?
- What’s a country that’s ruined all other countries for you?
- Real talk. How much of your day disappears into your phone?
- After a brutal work week, what’s your reset button?
I am not qualified to comment on the efficacy of dating apps. I spent my time in the library and actually tried to learn a few things in high school and college. Another honors student took pity on me, and we have been married for 58 years. Go figure.
However, i am qualified to make some observations about a government system using smart software. For my example I will assume that SpaceX’s Grok system is inserted into the Singaporean process. [Note: Madame Brousse, one of the crime fighters in the French judiciary has identified Elon Musk as a person of interest. She has Pavel Durov under the thumb of J3, and she appears to want Elon Musk similarly controlled.] Based on my team’s tests of Grok in its various forms, the system appears to take a somewhat relaxed approach to image and content generation. I think those assisting me are capable, but like any humanoid, errors can creep in. Therefore, I will assume that Madama Brousse’s objections to the kiddo pix some assert emerge from Grok. We generated awful cartoons better suited to a Donald Duck comic book.
Now let’s hypothesize about what might happen with Grok processing the survey inputs:
- Untoward pictures of those filling out the form. The possibilities are limitless and tantalizing, particularly to Singaporean government officials. (Yikes!)
- Cross correlation based on travel and country likes and dislikes. One can imaging smart software outputting those individuals with tendencies indicative of anti-government beliefs or actions. (Yikes, yikes!)
- Matching individuals the LLM determines are predisposed to accept and propagate the beliefs that make Singapore the utopia of southeast Asia; for example, harsh penalties for throwing trash in the street. (Yikes, yikes, yikes!)
I urge you to leave to your experience with LLMs, their respect for privacy , and their uncanny ability to output false or hallucinated information. Many exciting use cases can be envisioned. Maybe surveillance, identifying persons of interest, eugenics, LinkedIn censorship, etc.?
Stephen E Arnold, October 6, 2026
eTools: Privacy and a New Swiss Search Service
June 4, 2026
Another dinobaby post. No AI unless it is an image. This dinobaby is not Grandma Moses, just Grandpa Arnold.
In one of my feeds, I spotted a link to a service more than 15 years old as I recall. I think the operator is Comcepta. The firm’s Web site explains enterprise metasearch.
There is a mobile, consumer facing version of the system. eTools.ch pops up an interesting message:
I know this is difficult to read. Here’s the text:
On this website we use cookies and similar functions to process end device information and personal data (e.g. such as IP-addresses or browser information). The processing is used for purposes such as to integrate content, external services and elements from third parties, statistical analysis/measurement, personalized advertising and the integration of social media. Depending on the function, data is passed on to up to 304 third parties and processed by them. This consent is voluntary, not required for the use of our website and can be revoked at any time using the icon on the bottom left.
I captured the names of the third party outfits this Swiss outfit works with. A person using this system on a mobile device will have some information shared with lots of companies. Here’s a snip from the master list of 304. I pulled the vendors from “G” to “L.” How many do you recognize? Also, in the screenshot of the cookie control panel, please, notice there is no option to disable “all” of these third party services.
GeoEdge GfK GmbH Glomex GmbH Google Ads Google Advertising Products Google Analytics Google General Google Recaptcha Grabit Interactive Media Inc. dba KERV Interactive GumGum Australia, Inc. GumGum, Inc. Happydemics Hearts and Science München GmbH Human Hybrid Adtech GmbH ID5 Technology Ltd. Impactify SARL Improve Digital Index Exchange Inc. INFOnline GmbH Innovid LLC InMobi Technology Services Pte. Ltd. Inskin Media LTD Intercept Interactive Inc. dba Undertone Invibes Group IPONWEB GmbH jsdelivr.com Kairos Fire Knorex Krush Media LLC Kupona GmbH Kwanko LIFT DSP LIMITED LinkedIn LinkedIn Ireland Unlimited Company LiveIntent Inc. LiveRamp LoopMe Limited
I did not run any queries on the mobile service because I did not have one of my special devices with me. I am not sure how much storage these thrid party services consume. I am not sure I want to be “tracked.”
My recollection is that this eTools.ch service sends a user’s queries to open source indexes and some commercial services. Different deals are offered to gain access to a Web index outfit’s content. The results are retrieved and displayed to the user. The method is called “metasearch.” A similar service (originally developed by a finance type in New York City) is StartPage.com. (I am not sure who owns this service now.) Comcepta does provide some information about how its system works. I looked at the block diagram. The approach uses the same XML configuration file approach that Vivisimo did when it was in the search business.
The eTools.ch service emphasizes that it is “transparent.” I want to point out that the system has been around for more than a decade. What’s interesting is that Switzerland is one of the countries that harbors a number of private and privacy centric services. Banks come to mind as well as Proton’s services.
I want to point out that “privacy” in Switzerland does not pay much attention to what third party vendors do with information. The idea is that the vendor allegedly does not performl server-side profiling of users and doesn’t monetize query logs. What these third-party vendors do is not a problem for the regulators or the vendor.
The reason I posted this is to answer the question, “Where can I get a current list of third party vendors who might enter into a deal to help a Web site or service operator to generate some revenue?”
Here’s your answer: eTool.ch.
PS. I did not see “artificial intelligence” or “smart software” mentioned when I checked out the Web site.
Stephen E Arnold, June 4, 2026
A Peek into the Thiel-iverse
February 26, 2026
Another dinobaby post. No AI unless it is an image. This dinobaby is not Grandma Moses, just Grandpa Arnold.
I don’t pay much attention to Palantir. After I saw the firm run an ad in the Wall Street Journal explaining that it was an AI company, I dropped it from my intelware watch list. Palantir, I concluded, was an open source surfing custom software shop. It was essentially building solutions for customers. There’s nothing wrong with that approach, but I prefer outfits like Octostar who just sell a license. The customer is ready to roll after a short training course.
I read two items I found interesting. The link between the two is Peter Thiel, not the companies themselves. Let’s look briefly at these two items. Please, read each in its original form and assemble your own opinion about the messages contained in each “real” news item.

Thanks, Venice.ai. Good enough.
The first article is in the UK newspaper The Telegraph. Its story is “HS Contractor Palantir Will Suffer $200bn Wipeout, Says Big Short Investor.” The write up reports, “Michael Burry accuses ‘easily replaceable’ tech firm of overplaying its AI credentials.”
I found this snippet interesting:
Under its latest contract with the NHS, Palantir was tasked with joining up existing NHS data in a bid to speed up diagnosis and reduce waiting times and hospital stays. However, official figures this week showed that A&E trolley waits have risen to their worst on record – with more NHS patients than ever facing 12-hour delays last month.
Not unusual. Years ago I had a client with a juicy NHS contract. The client’s software did a couple of things, but to do heavy lifting such as that required by the NHS, custom code had to be written. My client could not meet the requirement and its contract was not renewed. Was it the NHS’ fault? Was my client responsible? I have no idea. But custom software required for a product that does a couple of things often presents challenges. Palantir is now tackling the NHS, and it has an alleged US$200 billion to help out the NHS with some fundamental issues.
He [an expert named Michael Burry] said its chief executive, Alex Karp, had initially been “blindsided by ChatGPT” and other large language models, only then to decide that he could “spin this as Palantir is AI”. Mr Burry said: “Like Trump, Karp figures bluster has gotten him pretty far, and so will continue in that mode.” Palantir has previously hit back against Mr Burry’s criticism. In late 2025, Mr Karp branded the investor “bats–t crazy” for predicting such sharp falls in its stock.
Yep, professional.
The second article is “Discord Distances Itself From Age Verification Firm After Ties To Palantir’s Peter Thiel Surface.” This write up states:
Started in 2018, Persona develops identity detection and anti-fraud technologies. They’ve been having an absolute field day since the OSA, being implemented to verify user ID across Reddit and Roblox. One sticking point, however, is who’s backing the company: Peter Thiel, the cofounder of ICE-approved surveillance firm Palantir.
The write up points out:
Thiel, of course, is known for many things. A co-founder of PayPal, Thiel is now more closely affiliated with Palantir, a company specializing in digital surveillance and exploiting user information.
My reaction to the Thiel thread linking these two items is that:
- Aggressive marketing is working for Palantir
- Mr. Thiel has a knack for spotting “in between” opportunities; that is, pools of high value information and customers like governments
- Some people like Mr. Burry and the author of the Discord article are nervous about the companies and, I surmise, Mr. Thiel.
Is it possible that Mr. Thiel and other influential Silicon Valley professionals want to use their technology to create an on ramp for themselves and their companies to gain not just more money but direct influence over the government and the citizens of a country?
A partial answer might be found in the public statements of thinkers like Nick Land, Patrick Deneen, and Curtis Yarvin. The touchstone old timer may be René Girard or Leo Strauss. Some of the ideas might shed light on Mr. Thiel’s investments, his support of the Palantir approach to marketing, and the funding of outfits like Persona.
Getting fascinated with an individual chess piece is necessary, but the game is won by trying to figure out the strategy of the player. That’s why I don’t follow Palantir. It is the bigger picture into which Palantir fits that matters.
Stephen E Arnold, February 26, 2026
A Meta Believe It or Not: No Spying on Our Users. No, No, No
October 24, 2025
This essay is the work of a dumb dinobaby. No smart software required.
Why worry about the data big tech collect about users. The grannies at the European Union wring their hands. In the US, it’s no problemo. Therefore, social media companies, cellphone and Internet providers, Kroger-like grocery chains, and even the local utility monopolies harvest data and sell it to advertisers. Case in point: I was speaking with a friend about a particular coffee brand I enjoy on a private text. When I turned on my TV, I saw a commercial for that exact same coffee brand. Coincidence? Sure, just like those ads for puffy jackets on Web sites after I buy a nifty blue puffer on Amazon. Yeah, I am going to buy another puffy after I just bought one.
That’s scarier than a R-rated horror movie and dumber.
Big Tech companies like Meta assure consumers they aren’t spying on them, but The Verge suspects otherwise: “Adam Mosseri’s ‘We’re Totally Not Spying On You’ Video Is Raising A Lot Of Questions."
Meta announced it will soon use AI chats to personalize ads. In poor timing, Adam Mosseri released a myth breaking video that attempted to assure users that Meta is not listening in on their conversations or reading their messages.
Meta’s ad system, however, is precise to the point of paranormal activity. Mosseri did offer explanations that reads like digital cookies and lies:
One, maybe you actually tapped on something that was related or even searched for that product online on a website, maybe before you had that conversation. We actually do work with advertisers who share information with us about who is on their website to try to target those people with ads. So if you were looking at a product on a website, then that advertiser might have paid us to reach you with an ad.
Two, we show people ads that we think that they’re interested in, or products we think they’re interested in, in part based on what their friends are interested in and what similar people with similar interests are interested in. So it could be that you were talking to someone about a product, and they, before, had to actually looked for or searched for that product, or that, in general, people with similar interests were doing the exact same thing.
Three, you might have actually seen that ad before you had a conversation and not realized it. We scroll quickly, we scroll by ads quickly, and sometimes you internalize some of that, and that actually affects what you talk about later.
Four, random chance, coincidence, it happens.”
Yeah, coincidence. Humans are programmed to notice patterns in their environment. It’s a survival instinct. Many of these patterns have transformed into odd conspiracy theories and rampant paranoia. Back in the day, these “coincidences” could have been chalked up to odd circumstances. Now it’s because Big Tech is watching. Anyone want a cup of coffee?
Whitney Grace, October 21, 2025
Graphite: Okay, to License Now
September 24, 2025
The US government uses specialized software to gather information related to persons of interest. The brand of popular since NSO Group marketed itself into a pickle is from the Israeli-founded spyware company Paragon Solutions. The US government isn’t a stranger to Paragon Solutions, in fact, El Pais shares in the article, “Graphite, the Israeli Spyware Acquired By ICE” that it renewed its contract with the specialized software company.
The deal was originally signed during Biden’s administration during September 24, but it went against the then president’s executive order that prohibited US agencies from using spyware tools that “posed ‘significant counterintelligence and security risks’ or had been misused by foreign governments to suppress dissent.
During the negotiations, AE Industrial Partners purchased Paragon and merged it with REDLattice, an intelligence contractor located in Virginia. Paragon is now a domestic partner with deep connections to former military and intelligence personnel. The suspension on ICE’s Homeland Security Investigations was quietly lifted on August 29 according to public contracting announcements.
The Us government will use Paragon’s Graphite spyware:
“Graphite is one of the most powerful commercial spy tools available. Once installed, it can take complete control of the target’s phone and extract text messages, emails, and photos; infiltrate encrypted apps like Signal and WhatsApp; access cloud backups; and covertly activate microphones to turn smartphones into listening devices.
The source suggests that although companies like Paragon insist their tools are intended to combat terrorism and organized crime, past use suggests otherwise. Earlier this year, Graphite allegedly has been linked to info gathering in Italy targeting at least some journalists, a few migrant rights activists, and a couple of associates of the definitely worth watching Pope Francis. Paragon stepped away from the home of pizza following alleged “public outrage.”
The US government’s use of specialized software seems to be a major concern among Democrats and Republicans alike. What government agencies are licensing and using Graphite. Beyond Search has absolutely no idea.
Whitney Grace, September 24, 2025
Which Browsers Devour the Most User Data?
May 19, 2025
Those concerned about data privacy may want to consider some advice from TechRadar: “These Are the Worst Web Browsers for Sucking Up All Your Data, So You May Want to Stop Using Them.” Citing research from Surfshark, writer Benedict Collins reports some of the most-used browsers are also the most ravenous. He tells us:
“Analyzing download statistics from AppMagic, Surfshark found Google’s Chrome and Apple‘s Safari account for 90% of the world’s mobile browser downloads. However, Chrome sucks up 20 different types of data while being used, including contact info, location, browsing history, and user content, and is the only browser to collect payment methods, card numbers, or bank account details. … Microsoft‘s Bing took second place for data collection, hoovering up 12 types of data, closely followed by Pi Browser in third place with nine data types, with Safari and Firefox collecting eight types and sharing fourth place.”
Et tu, Firefox? Collins notes the study found Brave and Tor to be the least data-hungry. The former collects identifiers and usage data. Tor, famously, collects no data at all. Both are free, though Brave sells add-ons and Tor accepts donations. The write-up continues:
“When it comes to the types of data collected, Pi Browser, Edge, and Bing all collected the most tracking data, usually sold to third parties to be used for targeted advertising. Pi Browser collects browsing history, search history, device ID, product interaction, and advertisement data, while Edge collects customer support request data, and Bing collects user ID data.”
For anyone unfamiliar, Pi Browser is designed for use with decentralized (blockchain) applications. We learn that, on mobile devices in the US, Chrome captures 43% of browser usage, while Safari captures 50%. Collins reminds readers there are ways to safeguard one’s data, though we would add none are total or foolproof. He also points us to TechRadar’s guide to the best VPNs for another layer of security.
Cynthia Murrell, May 19, 2025
Content Injection Can Have Unanticipated Consequences
February 24, 2025
The work of a real, live dinobaby. Sorry, no smart software involved. Whuff, whuff. That’s the sound of my swishing dino tail. Whuff.
Years ago I gave a lecture to a group of Swedish government specialists affiliated with the Forestry Unit. My topic was the procedure for causing certain common algorithms used for text processing to increase the noise in their procedures. The idea was to input certain types of text and numeric data in a specific way. (No, I will not disclose the methods in this free blog post, but if you have a certain profile, perhaps something can be arranged by writing benkent2020 at yahoo dot com. If not, well, that’s life.)
We focused on a handful of methods widely used in what now is called “artificial intelligence.” Keep in mind that most of the procedures are not new. There are some flips and fancy dancing introduced by individual teams, but the math is not invented by TikTok teens.
In my lecture, the forestry professionals wondered if these methods could be used to achieve specific objectives or “ends”. The answer was and remains, “Yes.” The idea is simple. Once methods are put in place, the algorithms chug along, some are brute force and others are probabilistic. Either way, content and data injections can be shaped, just like the gizmos required to make kinetic events occur.
The point of this forestry excursion is to make clear that a group of people, operating in a loosely coordinated manner can create data or content. Those data or content can be weaponized. When ingested by or injected into a content processing flow, the outputs of the larger system can be fiddled: More emphasis here, a little less accuracy there, and an erosion of whatever “accuracy” calculations are used to keep the system within the engineers’ and designers’ parameters. A plebian way to describe the goal: Disinformation or accuracy erosion.
I read “Meet the Journalists Training AI Models for Meta and OpenAI.” The write up explains that journalists without jobs or in search of extra income are creating “content” for smart software companies. The idea is that if one just does the Silicon Valley thing and sucks down any and all content, lawyers might come calling. Therefore, paying for “real” information is a better path.
Please, read the original article to get a sense of who is doing the writing, what baggage or mind set these people might bring to their work.
If the content is distorted — either intentionally or unintentionally — the impact of these content objects on the larger smart software system might have some interesting consequences. I just wanted to point out that weaponized information can have an impact. Those running smart software and buying content assuming it is just fine, might find some interesting consequences in the outputs.
Stephen E Arnold, February 24, 2025
Can the UN Control the Intelligence Units of Countries? Yeah, Sure. No Problem
January 16, 2025
This blog post is the work of an authentic dinobaby. Sorry. No smart software can help this reptilian thinker.
I assume that the information in “Governments Call for Spyware Regulations in UN Security Council Meeting” is spot on or very close to the bull’s eye. The write up reports:
On Tuesday [January 14, 2025] , the United Nations Security Council held a meeting to discuss the dangers of commercial spyware, which marks the first time this type of software — also known as government or mercenary spyware — has been discussed at the Security Council. The goal of the meeting, according to the U.S. Mission to the UN, was to “address the implications of the proliferation and misuse of commercial spyware for the maintenance of international peace and security.” The United States and 15 other countries called for the meeting.
Not surprisingly, different countries had different points of view. These ranged from “we have local regulations” to giant nation state assertions about bad actions by governments being more important to it is the USA’s fault.
The write up from the ubiquitous intelligence commentator did not include any history, context, or practical commentary about the diffusion of awareness of intelware or what the article, the UN, and my 90 year old neighbor calls spyware.
The public awareness of intelware coincided with hacks of some highly regarded technology. I am not going to name this product, but if one pokes about one might find documentation, code snippets, and even some conference material. Ah, ha. The conference material was obviously designed for marketing. Yes, that is correct. Conferences are routinely held in which the participants are vetted and certain measures put in place to prevent leakage of these materials. However, once someone passes out a brochure, the information is on the loose and can be snagged by a curious reporter who wants to do good. Also, some conference organizers themselves make disastrous decisions about what to post on their conference web site; for example, the presentations. I give some presentations at these closed to the public events, and I have found my slide deck on the organizer’s Web site. I won’t mention this outfit, but I don’t participate in any events associated with this outfit. Also, some conference attendees dress up as sheep and register with possibly bogus information. These folks happily snap pictures of exhibits of hardware not available to the public, record audio, and at one event held in the Hague sat in front of me and did a recording of my lecture about some odd ball research project in which I was involved. I reported the incident to the people at the conference desk. I learned that the individual left the conference and that his office telephone number was bogus. That’s enough. Leaks do occur. People are careless. Others just clever and duplicitous.
Thanks, You.com. You are barely able to manage a “good enough” these days. Money problems? Yeah, too bad. My heart bleeds for you.
However, the big reveal of intelware and its cousin policeware coincided with the push by one nation state. I won’t mention the country, but here’s how I perceived what kicked into high gear in 2005 or so. A number of start ups offered data analytics. The basic pitch was that these outfits had developed a suite of procedures to make sense of data. If the client had data, these companies could import the information and display important points identified by algorithms about the numbers, entities, and times. Marketers were interested in these systems because, like the sale pitches for AI today, the Madison Avenue crowd could dispense with the humans doing the tedious hand work required to make sense of pharmaceutical information. Buy, recycle, or create a data set. Then import it into these systems. Business intelligence spills forth. Leaders in this field did not disclose their “roots” in the intelligence community of the nation encouraging its entrepreneurs to commercialize what they learned when fulfilling their government military service.
Where did the funding come from? The nation state referenced provided some seed funds. However, in order to keep these systems in line with customer requirements for analyzing the sales of shampoo and blockbuster movies. Venture firms with personnel familiar with the nation state’s government software innovations were invited to participate in funding some of these outfits. One of them is a very large publicly traded company. This firm has a commercial sales side and a government sales side. Some readers of this post will have the stock in their mutual fund stock baskets. Once a couple of these outfits hit the financial jackpot for the venture firms, the race was on.
Companies once focused squarely on serving classified entities in a government in a number of countries wanted to sanitize the software and sell to a much larger, more diverse corporate market. Today, if one wants to kick the tires of commercially available once-classified systems and methods, one can:
- Attend conferences about data brokering
- Travel to Barcelona or Singapore and contact interesting start ups and small businesses in the marketing data analysis business
- Sign up for free open source intelligence online events and note the names and organizations speaking. (Some of these events allow a registered attendee to conduct an off line for others but real time chat with a speaker who represents an interesting company.
There are more techniques as well to identify outfits which are in the business of providing or developing intelware and policeware tools for anyone with money. How do you find these folks? That’s easy. Dark Web searches, Telegram Group surfing, and running an advertisement for a job requiring a person with specialized experience in a region like southeast Asia.
Now let me return to the topic of the cited article: The UN’s efforts to get governments to create rules, controls, or policies for intelware and policeware. Several observations:
- The effort is effectively decades too late
- The trajectory of high powered technology is outward from its original intended purpose
- Greed because the software works and can generate useful results: Money or genuinely valuable information.
Agree or disagree with me? That’s okay. I did a few small jobs for a couple of these outfits and have just enough insight to point out that the article “Governments Call for Spyware Regulations in UN Security Council Meeting” presents a somewhat thin report and lacks color.
Stephen E Arnold, January 18, 2025
Will AI Data Scientists Become Street People?
November 4, 2024
Over at HackerNoon, all-around IT guy Dominic Ligot insists data scientists must get on board with AI or be left behind. In “AI Denialism,” he compares data analysts who insist AI can never replace them with 19th century painters who scoffed at photography as an art form. Many of them who specialized in realistic portraits soon found themselves out of work, despite their objections.
Like those painters, Ligot believes, some data scientists are in denial about how well this newfangled technology can do what they do. They hang on to a limited definition of creativity at their peril. In fact, he insists:
“The truth is, AI’s ability to model complex relationships, surface patterns, and even simulate multiple solutions to a problem means it’s already doing much of what data analysts claim as their domain. The fine-grained feature engineering, the subtle interpretations—AI is not just nibbling around the edges; it’s slowly encroaching into the core of what we’ve traditionally defined as ‘analytical creativity.’”
But we are told there is hope for those who are willing to adapt:
“I’m not saying that data scientists or analysts will be replaced overnight. But to assume that AI will never touch their domain simply because it doesn’t fit into an outdated view of what creativity means is shortsighted. This is a transformative era, one that calls for a redefinition of roles, responsibilities, and skill sets. Data analysts and scientists who refuse to keep an open mind risk finding themselves irrelevant in a world that is rapidly shifting beneath their feet. So, let’s not make the same mistake as those painters of the past. Denialism is a luxury we cannot afford.”
Is Ligot right? And, if so, what skill-set changes can preserve data scientists’ careers? That relevant question remains unanswered in this post. (There are good deals on big plastic mugs at Dollar Tree.)
Cynthia Murrell, November 04, 2024

